Wednesday 11 January 2012

Civil Service Pension Schemes and unintended consequences



My Partner is a Doctor.  One of the things she is currently v. unhappy about (ignoring the general state of the NHS) is her pension.
She belongs to the old scheme (N/80ths NRA 60) and quite soon she will be moved across into the new scheme.  The BMA gave her some details on the proposals last week.
I did warn her at the time that they fluffed the review on '08 and that the arrangement is just not sustainable, but stopped myself short of the 'I told you so' moment, the reason being that having read the details, I cannot be sure that she is worse off.

Before :
N/80ths pension + 3N/80ths cash, NRA 60
After :
N/54ths, NRA 67.
The early retirement factor is due to be about 5% (not confirmed).
So this becomes 54 * 1.05^7 = 80ths

So, on the face of it, the you get about 25% less pension (the cash) and pay 3% more for the privilege.

Hold on though, the salary used to calculate the benefit is not Final Salary anymore, it is the salary in year, revalued by CPI + 1.5%.
If (for the sake of argument), there are 15 years between retirement and age 60

So, if the govt keeps NHS pay-rises below CPI+1.5% - just 0.5% per annum, the difference is slowly eroded.
Indeed CPI+1% would be a better pay rise that she has had for the last 3 years.

No comments:

Post a Comment